Why you shouldn’t succumb to stock market pessimism

A brutal first week of September was a reminder not to underestimate the impact of the seasons on investor sentiment. We have come back from our holidays fearing the worst and duly finding confirmation in the data. It’s natural to become gloomier as the evenings draw in, more susceptible to negative signals like last week’s disappointing US jobs report.

The glass-half-empty, autumnal view looks something like this: the economy is finally slowing after two years of rate hikes; valuations are high after 23 months of share price gains since 2022’s downturn; the Federal Reserve has stopped worrying about inflation and is rightly focused on growth - it may cut interest rates by half a percentage point next week; bonds and gold are outperforming shares as recession looms; oh, and it’s September - the next two months are historically the worst of the year for investors.

If you are looking for a more technical reason to worry, the relationship between the yield on short-term bonds and longer-dated ones has also raised a red flag. For two years short rates have been higher than long ones, which is what happens when central banks are squeezing the economy with high interest rates to rein in inflation. This ‘inverted yield curve’ is the classic sign that a slowdown is on its way. Last week, short and long rates flipped over, in anticipation of what’s expected to be a change of direction from the Fed next week. Short rates are now lower than long ones. That ‘un-inversion’ of the yield curve typically happens when the slowdown has actually arrived.

No surprise then that the days following the Labor Day holiday in America were the worst start to a month all year. The S&P 500 fell 4% and the growth-sensitive Nasdaq was 6% off. The shares most exposed to a slowdown, and particularly those that have benefited from the AI growth story, bore the brunt of the sell-off. Nvidia fell 20% in three weeks.

The tech sell-off has played into the hands of the seasonal pessimists because it has disguised a healthier market than the drop in the headline index level might suggest. The Magnificent Seven have underperformed the equal-weighted S&P 500 index by nearly 10% over the past three months. At the same time, smaller companies have broken out upwards from a two-year slumber. Nearly three quarters of shares are in an uptrend. Earnings forecasts for 2024 as a whole continue to look for near double digit growth.

We find ourselves in the curious situation where the market indices that we all watch closely could be falling even as most shares are still grinding higher. It’s easy to be blinded by the headline level of the market and to miss the opportunities lurking below the surface. As they say, it’s a market of stocks not a stock market.

Which raises a broader question about why the pessimistic view of the market is so seductive. Or, as Morgan Housel says in his excellent book The Psychology of Money, ‘pessimism holds a special place in our hearts. It sounds smarter. It’s intellectually captivating and it’s paid more attention than optimism, which is often viewed as being oblivious to risk.’

Pessimism sounds clever. But it only rarely makes sense for investors. The progression of stock markets over the long haul has rightly been labelled by investment historians Elroy Dimson, Mike Staunton and Paul Marsh as ‘the triumph of the optimists’. As Housel also said, ‘if you want to do better as an investor, the single most powerful thing you can do is increase your time horizon’. One of the underappreciated reasons Warren Buffett got so rich is that he started young and is still going strong in his nineties.

So, why do we fall for the pessimists’ fallacy? A few reasons. First, there’s a good evolutionary reason to see danger all around us. As Daniel Kahneman, author of another great book on behavioural investing, Thinking, Fast and Slow, says: ‘organisms that treat threats as more urgent than opportunities have a better chance to survive and reproduce.’ But what kept us alive on the savannah, also encourages us to be over-cautious investors.

Second, pessimism has the edge over optimism when it comes to money because when something bad happens in the financial world it affects us all, unlike say a weather event or a motorway pile up, which can be catastrophic for some but leave the rest of us completely unaffected. Even if you don’t own shares, a drop in the stock market may lead to you or someone in your family losing their job in due course. Fewer than 3% of Americans owned shares in 1929 but the market crash triggered the Great Depression.

Third, pessimism can be self-feeding because of our tendency to extrapolate in straight lines. We forget that the economy is always adapting. Take oil production, which rose from five million barrels a day in America in 2008 to 13 million by 2019. The reason was that the oil price, which had been $20 a barrel in 2001, rose to nearly $140 in 2008. The incentives changed and, as a consequence, the arithmetic of supply and demand did too.

Finally, pessimism trumps optimism because positive change is often slow and imperceptible while bad things happen in a rush. Housel points to a 70% drop in deaths from heart disease in the 50 years from 1965. ‘We could have a Hurricane Katrina five times a week, every week and it would not offset the number of annual lives saved by the decline in heart disease.’

As we get the logs in and draw the curtains earlier in the evening, it’s easy to focus on what could go wrong this autumn. But it’s not an investment strategy.

This article was originally published in The Telegraph.

Important information - investors should note that the views expressed may no longer be current and may have already been acted upon. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future returns. Overseas investments will be affected by movements in currency exchange rates. Reference to specific securities should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell these securities and is included for the purposes of illustration only. This information is not a personal recommendation for any particular investment. If you are unsure about the suitability of an investment you should speak to one of Fidelity’s advisers or an authorised financial adviser of your choice.